It seems when I was at school today my mom went to the Goodwill for me. There were two bags. I can't remember which were in what bags so I'll just list them all together according to generations.

G1:
-Heart Throb- Probably the baitiest pony I've ever seen in real life. She has a chewed up face, and a chewed up back left hoof. Some glitter loss. So sad.
-Whizzer- Her head appears to have been taken off before, though it doesn't turn. She has a very small hole (like sewing needle size) that you can't see unless your close up to her. So, not to baity.
-Twinkler- She has a Sharpie mark above her right eye. Other than that, she's in mint condition.
-Moonstone- some small marker marks and dirt, that's it. Not to baity.
-Baby Gory- a small orange mark on her DS neck. And a pink spot on NDS neck (near where the line separates the body and head) and then some regrind (?) down her front NDS leg. I'd call her near mint.

G3:
-Sunny Daze- Variant with the turnable head. No hoof heart. Version with a hole in foot. 2006. Some marker marks on her. Her tail appears to have gotten a sticky liquid in it. Very rough and clumped together.
-Moondancer- YES Now my Moondancer with a chewed off ear is now a bait! So this one will replace her. Matted mane and tail, but that can be fixed. Other than that one fixable thing, she's mint.
-Star Catcher- Some black marks on her head (DS) and marks on the NDS of some hooves. Not that bad
-Cotton Candy- chewed hoof with a hoof heart. And a marker mark on her DS face. Since I have a mint one already, I will customize this one.
-Rainbow Dash- non Core 7. Chew marks on her DS front hoof (with the hear on it). Matted hair.
-Twinkle Twirl- Matted hair.
-Sweetberry- matted hair. Some marker marks on NDS.
-Strawberry Reef- To quote Sweetie Belle: "I REALLY LIKE HER MANE!" Yeah. A blue mark on her NDS front leg. Other than that, she's mint.
-Sunset Sweetie- Chew marks on bother her DS hooves. Is it me, or does she really look a lot like Bumblesweet? Them having the same pose really doesn't help that issue! XD
-Guava Lava- Matted mane and tail. Minor marker marks. Near mint.

G4:
-Twilight Sparkle- Matted mane and tail. Part of her mane is stuck inside her neck. I managed to pull it out, but now hear head is slightly loose. I'm going to customize her.

McDs:
-G3 Butterscotch
-G3 Ponyville Desert Rose
-G3.5 Star Song
-G3.5 Sweetie Belle

Then there is also an accessory. It's a stethoscope.Green cord with pink at the end. Part that you put in your ears is blue. I think this came with G3 So Soft Cheerilee, didn't it?

So in the end, I got 20 ponies +1 accessory.

Sorry for the double post, the database error won't let me edit.

I went to the Goodwill again today, then went to Target.

Goodwill:
G3 Waterfire- I've wanted her for so long! <-- finally have her!
G3 Bow Tie
G3 Flower Garland
G3 Sparkleworks
McD G4 Fluttershy
3.5 Newborn Cuties Pinkie Pie

Then, at Target I got the Pony School Pals set and the Royal Castle Friends set. They also had the train, but I have to wait until next pay day for that.

Sounds like you found some nice ponies - none of the G1s are bait! Even if they have small flaws, there will be someone happy to have them in their collection!

I'm so jealous of you guys who have thrift stores with ponies in them!!

That is awesome! Congrats!

Your collection must be huge by now! Poor baity Heart-throb, it sounds like she has had a hard life

PS: I understand the double posting for now. The Arena really is having a hard time of things at the moment.

When I was younger I got a chewed-up Heart Throb too!

My mom used to go for ponies for me when I was at school also.

Sounds like you had a GREAT pony haul this week!!

Huge congrats

Those are some awesome thrift store finds! I can't wait til I find the Pony School Pals and Castle Friends sets here. They are so cute. Congrats on getting those!

lovesbabysquirmy wrote:

Sounds like you found some nice ponies - none of the G1s are bait! Even if they have small flaws, there will be someone happy to have them in their collection!

Well, in bait condition. I don't use ponies as baits until I have two of them and one of them is in bait condition. I'll probably custom Heart Throb once I get a better condition one. So, right now, she's in my collection being displayed (w/ a chewed face! XD).

Ok, double post again (if you mods can, edit this in my last post and simply delete this sentance).

Looks like my mom went to Value Village. I got A LOT of McD ponies I had already, so I'll just skip through those and head to the ones I didn't already have.

G3s:
McDs Core 7 Rainbow Dash
Sparkleworks (different pose than the one I posted about earlier)
Core 7 Sweetie Belle (symbol down leg. This one has an unremovable pen scribble on her DS face. So I'm gonna get an extra power magic eraser and carefully make sure I don't go over her eye)

G3.5s:
Rainbow Dash
Styling Star Song
Newborn Cuties Cheerilee

Oh, sounds like you got a lot of nice finds!

Congrats!

Congrats! That's a lot of ponies. Do consider carefully before baiting G1s though. Poor, poor Heart Throb does sound like she's seen better days. I have a movie version Firefly with some teeth marks on her face but I still love her lol. She's nothing close to chewed up though. The rest of your G1s sound great! And geeze, already a matted haired G4, huh?

I can't believe I forgot to mention two ponies I got at Value Village yesterday. Hula-Lula and Lavender Locket. Why I forgot them, I don't know. XD