PrincessAmalthea wrote:

lunar_scythe wrote: Traxxx wrote: I bought thistle whistle in a store O.o several of 'em, and used two for custom bait... erk, you probably could have traded each of them for 4-5 other ponies! There's only 2 listed on ebay, both BIN's of about $40-50.00 I was going by this: homepage.ntlworld.com/...histle.htm it says Thistle Whistle hadn't been released in stores, maybe she was just a very htf one? you're kidding right? We are talking about this pony: www.ponytopia.com/2005...histle.htm I got mine a month or so ago in a normal toy store.

My guess is that page hasn't been updated since the pony came out on eBay (first 50 sold by WIA)... Back tehn, yes it was true the pony has not been released to stores, but it has since then.

Just my guess about this misunderstanding

--Roz

I have a few of the BI 50 first and they are all the same as the store released ones.
Unfortunately they (the 50st) aren't worth much more than the normal MIB ones.

So far for the ones that got sold on ebay by worldinadvance (hasbro) as the 1st 50 pieces for that particular pony are:

- Cloud Climber
- Fairweather
- wondermint
- thistle whistle

and these ponies were all sold in stores. Just the 1st 50 pieces made got a special sticker stated that it was one of the first 50 produced.

yeah i know mlpmom, but it was one of those things to just find out since they have kinda went down underground on the radars lately.

found the checklist on www.ponytopia.com
2003
__ Kimono,
__ Pinkie Pie,
__ Rainbow Dash
__ Sunny Daze,
__ Wysteria,
__ Sweetberry
2004
__ Denim Blue
__ Rainbow Swirl
__ Peachy Pie
__ Desert Blossom
__ Star Dasher
__ Wondermint
__ Sapphire Shores
__ Piccolo
__ Spring Parade
__ Golden Delicious
__ Cinnamon Breeze
__ Heather Winds
__ Sweet Breeze
__ Magic Marigold
__ Gardenia Glow
__ Seaspray
__ Bow-tie
__ Beachberry
__ Kiwi Tart
__ Island Rainbow
__ Shell-belle
__ Fizzy Pop
__ Waterfire
2005
__ Bunches-O-Fun
__ Fair Weather
__ Alphabittle
__ Twilight Twinkle
Thistle Whistle, Lavender Lake, Tangerine Sunset, and Pineapple Paradise.
Beachcomber, Desert Palm, Summer Berry, and Cloud Climber.