You can take out as many as you like, as long as you replace them w/ something of equal value. You can put in one, or many - it just depends on how many you take out.

I'll be gone til after Christmas, so if someone else that knows swap boxes could answer any questions for me, I would be much oblidged!

I may be interested....I dont have feedback here yet but I have lots on EMLP board and ebay ok

i would be interested too...haven't done a swap box in a while- I look forward to it!

I would like to learn a little bit more about how it works exactly: I mean, if all the best stuff is taken out, wouldnt the last people to get the box not have much choice (or be disadvantaged in some way?).
Also, I only collect G1s, and I want to be sure that at least half of the box would be G1s (If the box only had one or two, it really wouldnt be worth it to me). IF the box is started with a good portion of G1s, can we make a rule that says all G1s must be replaced with G1s, and same rule goes for all ponies of other Gens, too? (Again, because if the box is started with a bunch of G1s, and they get replaced with G2s and G3s as the box travels, the last few people to get the box wouldnt have many G1s to choose from).

I really like this idea, so I'm sorry if I'm being a sourpuss, I just don't want to get all excited about this only to be disappointed when I receive the box.

I would love to join in! Unfortunately, I think I only have one feedback here (+ one at Ponyville). I've done one or two other transactions, but I don't think they left feedback for me :-( I have over 2100 positives on ebay. Too bad I can't count those :-/

That sounds like fun, but I've had my fill of swap boxes for a while!
Good luck!

Hey Prixton I was reading the first post over again and ajcoecoe said we may post wishlists when it's time to do such, so the person after us will have a pony or two that are on their list and not be disappointed ^_^ I think your idea of replacing G1's with G1's etc. would be a great idea, though it's hard for me to get hold of G1's and there aren't any in my collection I'm willing to give up if I choose a G1 from the box ^^"

Silver Healer,
I think that the wish list thing is a good idea, but what is the guarantee that someone would have a pony from our wishlist available to include for us? I guess I just feel that if I am only going to get one or two ponies out of it, and the rest of the box will be G2s or G3s that I have absolutely no interest in, then maybe its not worth it for me :(. It really makes me sad to say that though, because I think it is a great idea; if only everyone could be a G1 collector like me...